#HTML# <img src="bigmed-sigils.gif" align=right>
Conference Presentation Judo
****************************
M. J. Dominus
Plover Systems Co.
mjd-yapc-judo+@plover.com
#RTIMG# eyeball.jpg
June, 2002
* [R[CAUTION]R]: This talk may offer insight into the way I think
* [R[CAUTION]R]: I am cynical and elitist
----------------------------------------------------------------
Conference Presentations
************************
* Most tutorial speakers are pretty awful
* Some of this is just lack of practice
* Some is stage fright
* Some is lack of aptitude
* Some of it is easily correctable
* I've picked up a few tricks
* I will tell you all my dirty little secrets
================================================================
* My professional ones, I mean
----------------------------------------------------------------
Conference Presentations
************************
* I've been doing presentations at big conferences since 1998
* 40 hours of tutorials at TPC alone, also Usenix, LISA, YAPC, etc.
* I am consistently the highest-rated speaker at TPC
================================================================
### #RTIMG# conway-tooth.jpg
* Yup, even higher than Damian
----------------------------------------------------------------
The Biggest Mistake You Can Make
********************************
* I'm going to start big
* What is the biggest mistake you can make when making a conference presentation?
================================================================
#RTIMG# caught-short.jpg
* Forgetting to go to the bathroom beforehand
----------------------------------------------------------------
The Second Biggest Mistake You Can Make
***************************************
* Going to the bathroom beforehand
================================================================
#IMG# microphone.gif
* But forgetting to switch off the wireless mike
----------------------------------------------------------------
The Biggest Mistake You Can Make
********************************
* OK, seriously
* You didn't need me to tell you that
================================================================
* Or if you did, you were doomed anyway
* So what's the best advice I can give you that might _not_ be obvious?
----------------------------------------------------------------
The Single Biggest Mistake You Can Make
***************************************
#RTIMG# cake2.jpg
* Conference tutorials last three and a half hours
* Including a half-hour break in the middle
* During this break, coffee and cake are served
================================================================
* You _must not_ let the class out for break too early or too late
----------------------------------------------------------------
On Content
**********
* This talk is _Conference Presentation Judo_
* So I hope you were expecting me to talk about cake, not content
* So let's deal briefly with content
* Just to get it out of the way
----------------------------------------------------------------
On Content
**********
* The three most important factors in giving a good presentation are:
================================================================
1. Delivery
================================================================
2. Delivery
================================================================
3. Delivery
----------------------------------------------------------------
On Content
**********
#RTIMG# snowstorm.jpg
* Content is quaternary
* People come to conferences on vacation
* That is why they do not have them in Fargo
* The class is an _excuse_ for the vacation
* Your primary goal should be to entertain
* Study Damian. He is the master.
----------------------------------------------------------------
On Content
**********
* Of course, more content is always better
================================================================
#HTML# <br clear=right><img align=left src="boss.gif">
* You must also give them an idea that they learned something
* They need a plausible story to tell their boss when they get home
* But if you must choose, choose delivery over content
* With that disclaimer, the second biggest mistake you can make is content-related
----------------------------------------------------------------
The Big Content Mistake
***********************
#HTML# <p align=center><font color="green" size="+4">Do <b>not</b>
begin with a long general introduction.
#HTML# </font></p>
o You know how this goes
o Suppose the class is "Introduction to XML"
----------------------------------------------------------------
Introduction to XML -> What is XML?
***********************************
XML is:
* Structured
* Extensible
* Markup
* Language
* Internationalized
* Standardized
* Widely-Deployed
* Content-directed
* Application-oriented
* SGML-compliant
* Customizable
* Synergistic
* Incremental
* Functional
* Fruity-good
----------------------------------------------------------------
The Long Introduction
*********************
* Then they have a couple of slides on "XML's good points"
* Then they have a couple of slides on "XML's limitations"
* "What XML is used for"
* (Namedropping section)
* "History of XML"
* "Overview of the standardization process"
* Blah blah blah
* I give you my solemn word of honor that I am not thinking of any specific instructor here
----------------------------------------------------------------
The Long Introduction
*********************
* This stuff is all a waste of time
* Learning that "XML is content-directed" will not help anyone do anything
* People who don't know yet what XML is will pick it up from the examples
* If not, your examples are no good
* Get to specific technical information as quickly as possible
----------------------------------------------------------------
The Long Introduction
*********************
* A three-hour class is a _terrible_ way to learn anything
* _Nobody_ can remain attentive for that long
* Typical attention span: 45 minutes
* Therefore, you should front-load the class
* The _most important_ material in the first 45 minutes
* The Long Introduction squanders those precious first minutes
----------------------------------------------------------------
A Bit of Advice
***************
o You have probably heard:
#HTML# <p align=center><font color="red" size="+2">
Tell them what you're going to tell them; then tell them;
then tell them what you told them.
#HTML# </font></p>
================================================================
#RTIMG# bullshit.jpg
o Bullshit
o You only have three hours, bozo
o You can't waste twenty minutes at each end repeating stuff
o Besides, it's _boring_
================================================================
o My replacement for that advice:
#HTML# <p align=center><font color="red" size="+2">
Get to the point as quickly as possible.
#HTML# </font></p>
#HTML# <p align=center><font color="red" size="+2">
Stay there.
#HTML# </font></p>
#HTML# <p align=center><font color="red" size="+2">
Don't repeat; embellish.
#HTML# </font></p>
----------------------------------------------------------------
Get to the Point
****************
o Here's the introduction section of one of my tutorials
#HTML# <hr>
#HTML# <table width="80%"><tr><td><font size="-1">
What is This Class About?
*************************
o The _Iterator_ is a fundamental control structure, analogous to the loop
o What problems does it solve?
o When should you use it?
o How do you build one?
o Examples
o Generating DNA sequences
o Database searches
o Permutations
o Directory tree walker
o Web spider
#HTML# </font></td></tr></table>
#HTML# <hr>
o This is all the introduction you should need
o That list of examples was very carefully constructed
----------------------------------------------------------------
Get to the Point
****************
o The first example is introduced on slide 2
#HTML# <hr>
#HTML# <table width="80%"><tr><td><font size="-1">
#RTIMG# dna
Genomic Sequence Generator
**************************
o This is a real-world application
o A biologist wrote to ask me this question:
o Given a pattern like [[AT<GC>A<TA>]]
o Produce the strings [[ATGAT]], [[ATGAA]], [[ATCAT]], [[ATCAA]].
#HTML# </font></td></tr></table>
#HTML# <hr>
o Recursive code to solve this problem appears on slide 3
o Then I discuss the severe problems with that approach
o Shortly thereafter, the solution (iterators) appears
----------------------------------------------------------------
Illustrations
*************
#RTIMG# carrots.jpg
* OK, enough about content
* Back to presentation
* Have pictures on the slides
* Even if they are irrelevant
* They help wake people up
* And give their eyes and brains a rest
----------------------------------------------------------------
Illustrations
*************
* Of course, relevant is good too
* Metaphoric illustrations are also good
* Bright colors are a good idea
* Diagrams are always helpful
* I like to have pictures that commit atrocious puns
#IMG# autoload.jpg
----------------------------------------------------------------
Illustrations
*************
* If you have line drawings, make the lines two pixels thick
#HTML# <table align=center><tr>
#HTML# <td><img src="thinlines.gif"></td><td width="10%"></td><td><img src="thicklines.gif"></td>
#HTML# </tr></table>
* One-pixel lines are perfectly legible
* But the thicker lines look better
* It took me five years to figure this out
----------------------------------------------------------------
#RTIMG# earhart.jpg
#HTML# <img src="earhart.jpg" align=left>
Illustrations
*************
* Make sure pictures of people are _facing_ your text
* People will pay more attention if they see someone else paying attention
* Vice versa
----------------------------------------------------------------
Illustrations
*************
* This is the most cynical, manipulative trick I know:
================================================================
#IMG# happy-baby.JPG
* I have not yet tried using pictures of adorable kittens
----------------------------------------------------------------
Speed
*****
* Most instructors go too slowly
* A median (50%) rate is fine for undergrad classes
* Because everyone must pass the exam
#RTIMG# a-ko
* In a three-hour class, your strategy must be different
* The typical student will learn:
* One or two specific techniques
* A groundwork of more general understanding
* This will prepare them for later self-study
* Slower students will get this much whether you go quickly or slowly
* Faster ones will get more if you go faster
* I try to target the 75-80% mark
----------------------------------------------------------------
Speed
*****
#RTIMG# sleepy.jpg
* At any speed, not everyone will get everything
* Some people will fall off the bus
* Some will doze off
* So have many synchronization points along the way
* When someone gets lost, they can start over fresh at the next synchronization point
* If you use this strategy, even slower people will learn more
----------------------------------------------------------------
### #HTML# <img src="uri.jpg" align="left">
The Guy in the Second Row
*************************
* There seems to be one of these at every talk
* He's the one who thinks he's there to have a dialogue with you
* He always sits in the second row on the aisle
* I do not know why this is
* I originally planned to have a gallery of Guys in the Second Row I have known
* I decided it would be better to show a one incorrigible example
----------------------------------------------------------------
#HTML# <img src="mjd.jpg" align="left">
The Guy in the Second Row
*************************
* Sad but true
----------------------------------------------------------------
Questions
*********
* When someone in the audience asks a question, always repeat it
* Because the rest of the audience didn't hear it
* If _you_ couldn't hear it, ask them *politely* to repeat it more loudly
* If you still can't hear it, invite them to ask you after class
* Do _not_ yell at them to speak up
* People are nervous about speaking in big rooms full of people
----------------------------------------------------------------
Accordion Sections
******************
#RTIMG# accordion.jpg
* You never know just how long the class will take
* If you run out of time at slide 111 of 120, people will complain
* So always end on the last slide
================================================================
* Even if you have to skip a bunch of slides to get there on time
* Have the class end with an _accordion section_
* Many independent subtopics that can be discarded if necessary
----------------------------------------------------------------
#RTIMG# present.gif
The Bonus Section
*****************
o You are sure to discard some slides during the editing process
o If the talk is too long, you will cut some slides out
o If you add a new section one year, you'll take out the old one
o Do not throw these things away
o Put them at the end of the talk after the "thank you" slide
o Call this the 'bonus section'
o You will usually not discuss this material in person
o But it will appear in the back of the book
----------------------------------------------------------------
The Bonus Section
*****************
o This serves at least three functions
o If the class runs undertime, you can tour some bonus slides
o It delivers more value to your customers
o It will prevent stupid complaints about the book not having anything extra
o Many presenters like to append some random RFC or research paper for this reason
o The bonus section is more valuable
----------------------------------------------------------------
Digressions
***********
* Digressions are OK, but only if
* Relevant
* *or* Short
================================================================
* Second-order digressions must be both relevant *and* short
================================================================
* Third-order digressions: Do not.
----------------------------------------------------------------
Evaluations
***********
* Mostly worthless
* Every possible complaint will appear
* If one says the talk was too fast, that doesn't mean it was too fast
* Some other evaluation will say it was too slow
Covered too much / not enough material
Followed book too closely / not closely enough
Failed to cover the whole book / not enough extra material in the book
Did not answer enough questions / too much time answering questions
Class was too easy / too hard
----------------------------------------------------------------
Evaluations
***********
* Don't let this get you down
* You cannot win
* So do the talk in a way that preserves your professional dignity and integrity
* If _you_ are happy with the talk, that must be enough
----------------------------------------------------------------
Jokes
*****
#HTML# <p align=center><font color="red" size="+2">
Always begin with a joke.
#HTML# </font></p>
================================================================
#HTML# <img src="bullshit-sm.jpg" align=left>
* Bullshit
* Not everyone has a jocular personality
* If yours isn't, don't force it
* You must invent a stage persona that works well for you
* Play to your strengths, not your weaknesses
----------------------------------------------------------------
#RTIMG# kurt.jpg
Friendly Faces
**************
* Have a friend come and sit in the front row
* Then if you get nervous, you can look at your friend and see a friendly face
* I like to try to get Kurt Starsinic
================================================================
* He always laughs at all my jokes
================================================================
o Really loudly
----------------------------------------------------------------
Friendly Faces
**************
* If you don't have a friend in the audience, pick a friendly-looking stranger
* Focus on this person
* Sometimes nobody looks friendly
================================================================
#RTIMG# placido.jpg
* This is why I always bring an octopus
----------------------------------------------------------------
#RTIMG# smallchange.jpg
Small Change
************
o Remove all small change from your pockets beforehand
o Some speakers jingle their change for three hours without realizing it
----------------------------------------------------------------
Insults
*******
* Don't tell the audience what a bunch of idiots they are
* They hate that.
================================================================
* Instead, tell them what idiots some _other_ audience was
----------------------------------------------------------------
#RTIMG# comma.gif
Proofreading
************
o Proofread the slides very carefully
o Attendees are incredibly stingy about typos
o "I paid for every comma, and by God, I'm going to get them all."
o Giving a practice version of the talk is always a good idea
o In particular, the test audience will notice most of the remaining typos
----------------------------------------------------------------
Biggest Mistake I Ever Made
***************************
* At my first conference, I was doing a six-hour security tutorial
* I thought:
#HTML# <p align=center><font color="red" size="+2">
Security is very serious. People will want to know I am serious.
#HTML# </font></p>
================================================================
#HTML# <p align=center><font color="red" size="+2">
A suit will reassure the corporate types.
#HTML# </font></p>
#IMG# security-mjd.jpg
* I was thoroughly vilified for this
----------------------------------------------------------------
#RTIMG# sen.jpg
Thank You
*********
o I hope you were amused
o But I meant every word
----------------------------------------------------------------