# WordNet::Similarity::lesk.pm version 1.03 # (Last updated $Id: lesk.pm,v 1.28 2006/04/05 20:12:55 sidz1979 Exp $) # # Module to accept two WordNet synsets and to return a floating point # number that indicates how similar those two synsets are, using an # adaptation of the Lesk method as outlined in package WordNet::Similarity::lesk; =head1 NAME WordNet::Similarity::lesk - Perl module for computing semantic relatedness of word senses using gloss overlaps as described by Banerjee and Pedersen (2002) -- a method that adapts the Lesk approach to WordNet. =head1 SYNOPSIS use WordNet::Similarity::lesk; use WordNet::QueryData; my $wn = WordNet::QueryData->new(); my $lesk = WordNet::Similarity::lesk->new($wn); my $value = $lesk->getRelatedness("car#n#1", "bus#n#2"); ($error, $errorString) = $lesk->getError(); die "$errorString\n" if($error); print "car (sense 1) <-> bus (sense 2) = $value\n"; =head1 DESCRIPTION Lesk (1985) proposed that the relatedness of two words is proportional to to the extent of overlaps of their dictionary definitions. Banerjee and Pedersen (2002) extended this notion to use WordNet as the dictionary for the word definitions. This notion was further extended to use the rich network of relationships between concepts present is WordNet. This adapted lesk measure has been implemented in this module. =head2 Methods =over =cut use strict; use warnings; use Text::OverlapFinder; use WordNet::Similarity; use File::Spec; use WordNet::Similarity::GlossFinder; our @ISA = qw(WordNet::Similarity::GlossFinder); our $VERSION = '1.03'; WordNet::Similarity::addConfigOption ("normalize", 0, "i", 0); =item $measure->initialize($file) Overrides the initialize method in the parent class (GlossFinder.pm). This method essentially initializes the measure for use. Parameters: $file -- configuration file. Returns: none. =cut # Initialization of the WordNet::Similarity::lesk object... parses the config file and sets up # global variables, or sets them to default values. # INPUT PARAMS : $paramFile .. File containing the module specific params. # RETURN VALUES : (none) sub initialize { my $self = shift; my $paramFile; my $wn = $self->{wn}; my $class = ref $self || $self; # Stemming? Normalizing? $self->{stem} = 0; $self->{normalize} = 0; # Look for the default lesk relation file... if(!defined $self->{relationDefault}) { my $path; my $header; my @possiblePaths = (); # Look for all possible default data files installed. foreach $path (@INC) { # JM 1-16-04 -- modified to use File::Spec my $file = File::Spec->catfile($path, 'WordNet', 'lesk-relation.dat'); push @possiblePaths, $file if(-e $file); } # If there are multiple possibilities, get the one in the correct format. foreach $path (@possiblePaths) { next if(!open(RELATIONS, $path)); $header = ; $header =~ s/\s+//g; if($header =~ /RelationFile/) { $self->{relationDefault} = $path; close(RELATIONS); last; } close(RELATIONS); } } # Call the initialize method in the parent... $self->SUPER::initialize (@_); # initialize string compare module. No stemming in string # comparison, so put 0. #&string_compare_initialize(0, %stopHash); my @finder_args = (); if (defined $self->{stop}) { push @finder_args, stoplist => $self->{stop}; } # lesk doesn't use a comp file, so we can ignore that $self->{finder} = Text::OverlapFinder->new (@finder_args); } =item $lesk->traceOptions() This method is internally called to determine the extra options specified by this measure (apart from the default options specified in the WordNet::Similarity base class). Parameters: none. Returns: none. =cut # 12/5/03 JM (#1) # show all config options specific to this module sub traceOptions { my $self = shift; $self->{traceString} .= "normalize :: $self->{normalize}\n"; $self->SUPER::traceOptions(); } =item $lesk->getRelatedness Computes the relatedness of two word senses using the Extended Gloss Overlaps algorithm. Parameters: two word senses in "word#pos#sense" format. Returns: Unless a problem occurs, the return value is the relatedness score, which is greater-than or equal-to 0. If an error occurs, then the error level is set to non-zero and an error string is created (see the description of getError()). =cut sub getRelatedness { my $self = shift; my $wps1 = shift; my $wps2 = shift; my $wn = $self->{wn}; my $class = ref $self || $self; # Check the existence of the WordNet::QueryData object. unless($wn) { $self->{errorString} .= "\nError (${class}::getRelatedness()) - "; $self->{errorString} .= "A WordNet::QueryData object is required."; $self->{error} = 2; return undef; } # Using validation code from parseWps() in a super-class my $ret = $self->parseWps($wps1, $wps2); ref $ret or return undef; # Initialize traces. $self->{traceString} = ""; # Now check if the similarity value for these two synsets is in # fact in the cache... if so return the cached value. my $relatedness = $self->{doCache} ? $self->fetchFromCache ($wps1, $wps2) : undef; defined $relatedness and return $relatedness; # Now get down to really finding the relatedness of these two. # see if any traces reqd. if so, put in the synset arrays. if($self->{trace}) { # ah so we do need SOME traces! put in the synset names. $self->{traceString} = "Synset 1: $wps1\n"; $self->{traceString} .= "Synset 2: $wps2\n"; } # NOTE: Thanks to Wybo Wiersma for contributing optimizations # in the following code. # Get the gloss strings from the get_wn_info module my ($firstStringArray, $secondStringArray, $weightsArray, $functionsStringArray) = $self->getSuperGlosses($wps1, $wps2); my $score = 0; for(my $i = 0; $i < scalar(@{$weightsArray}); $i++) { my $functionsScore = 0; my $funcStringPrinted = 0; # so those are the two strings for this relation pair. get the # string overlaps my ($overlaps, $wc1, $wc2); if(defined($firstStringArray->[$i]) && defined($secondStringArray->[$i]) && $firstStringArray->[$i] ne "" && $secondStringArray->[$i] ne "") { ($overlaps, $wc1, $wc2) = $self->{finder}->getOverlaps($firstStringArray->[$i], $secondStringArray->[$i]); } my $overlapsTraceString = ""; my $key; foreach $key (keys %{$overlaps}) { # find the length of the key, square it, multiply with its # value and finally with the weight associated with this # relation pair to get the score for this particular # overlap. my @tempArray = split(/\s+/, $key); my $value = ($#tempArray + 1) * ($#tempArray + 1) * $overlaps->{$key}; $functionsScore += $value; # put this overlap into the trace string, if necessary if($self->{trace} == 1) { $overlapsTraceString .= "$overlaps->{$key} x \"$key\" "; } } # normalize the function score computed above if required if ($self->{normalize} && defined($wc1) && defined($wc2) && ($wc1 * $wc2)) { $functionsScore /= $wc1 * $wc2; } # weight functionsScore with weight of this function $functionsScore *= $weightsArray->[$i]; # add to main score for this sense $score += $functionsScore; # if we have an overlap, send functionsString, functionsScore # and overlapsTraceString to trace string, if trace string requested if($self->{trace} == 1 && $overlapsTraceString ne "") { $self->{traceString} .= "".($functionsStringArray->[$i]).": $functionsScore\n"; $funcStringPrinted = 1; $self->{traceString} .= "Overlaps: $overlapsTraceString\n"; } # check if the two strings need to be reported in the trace. if ($self->{trace} == 2) { if(!$funcStringPrinted) { $self->{traceString} .= "".($functionsStringArray->[$i])."\n"; $funcStringPrinted = 1; } $self->{traceString} .= "String 1: \"".($firstStringArray->[$i])."\"\n"; $self->{traceString} .= "String 2: \"".($secondStringArray->[$i])."\"\n"; } } # that does all the scoring. Put in cache if doing caching. Then # return the score. $self->{doCache} and $self->storeToCache($wps1, $wps2, $score); return $score; } 1; __END__ =back =head2 Usage The semantic relatedness modules in this distribution are built as classes that define the following methods: new() getRelatedness() getError() getTraceString() See the WordNet::Similarity(3) documentation for details of these methods. =head3 Typical Usage Examples To create an object of the lesk measure, we would have the following lines of code in the Perl program. use WordNet::Similarity::lesk; $measure = WordNet::Similarity::lesk->new($wn, '/home/sid/lesk.conf'); The reference of the initialized object is stored in the scalar variable '$measure'. '$wn' contains a WordNet::QueryData object that should have been created earlier in the program. The second parameter to the 'new' method is the path of the configuration file for the lesk measure. If the 'new' method is unable to create the object, '$measure' would be undefined. This, as well as any other error/warning may be tested. die "Unable to create object.\n" if(!defined $measure); ($err, $errString) = $measure->getError(); die $errString."\n" if($err); To find the semantic relatedness of the first sense of the noun 'car' and the second sense of the noun 'bus' using the measure, we would write the following piece of code: $relatedness = $measure->getRelatedness('car#n#1', 'bus#n#2'); To get traces for the above computation: print $measure->getTraceString(); However, traces must be enabled using configuration files. By default traces are turned off. =head1 CONFIGURATION FILE The behavior of the measures of semantic relatedness can be controlled by using configuration files. These configuration files specify how certain parameters are initialized within the object. A configuration file may be specified as a parameter during the creation of an object using the new method. The configuration files must follow a fixed format. Every configuration file starts with the name of the module ON THE FIRST LINE of the file. For example, a configuration file for the lesk module will have on the first line 'WordNet::Similarity::lesk'. This is followed by the various parameters, each on a new line and having the form 'name::value'. The 'value' of a parameter is optional (in case of boolean parameters). In case 'value' is omitted, we would have just 'name::' on that line. Comments are supported in the configuration file. Anything following a '#' is ignored till the end of the line. The module parses the configuration file and recognizes the following parameters: =over =item trace The value of this parameter specifies the level of tracing that should be employed for generating the traces. This value is an integer equal to 0, 1, or 2. If the value is omitted, then the default value, 0, is used. A value of 0 switches tracing off. A value of 1 or 2 switches tracing on. A value of 1 displays as traces only the gloss overlaps found. A value of 2 displays as traces all the text being compared. =item cache The value of this parameter specifies whether or not caching of the relatedness values should be performed. This value is an integer equal to 0 or 1. If the value is omitted, then the default value, 1, is used. A value of 0 switches caching 'off', and a value of 1 switches caching 'on'. =item maxCacheSize The value of this parameter indicates the size of the cache, used for storing the computed relatedness value. The specified value must be a non-negative integer. If the value is omitted, then the default value, 5,000, is used. Setting maxCacheSize to zero has the same effect as setting cache to zero, but setting cache to zero is likely to be more efficient. Caching and tracing at the same time can result in excessive memory usage because the trace strings are also cached. If you intend to perform a large number of relatedness queries, then you might want to turn tracing off. =item relation The value of this parameter is the path to a file that contains a list of WordNet relations. The path may be either an absolute path or a relative path. The lesk measure combines glosses of synsets related to the target synsets by these relations and then searches for overlaps in these "super-glosses." WARNING: the format of the relation file is different for the vector and lesk measures. =item stop The value of this parameter the path of a file containing a list of stop words that should be ignored in the glosses. The path may be either an absolute path or a relative path. =item stem The value of this parameter indicates whether or not stemming should be performed. The value must be an integer equal to 0 or 1. If the value is omitted, then the default value, 0, is used. A value of 1 switches 'on' stemming, and a value of 0 switches stemming 'off'. When stemming is enabled, all the words of the glosses are stemmed before their vectors are created for the vector measure or their overlaps are compared for the lesk measure. =item normalize The value of this parameter indicates whether or not normalization of scores is performed. The value must be an integer equal to 0 or 1. If the value is omitted, then the default value, 0, is assumed. A value of 1 switches 'on' normalizing of the score, and a value of 0 switches normalizing 'off'. When normalizing is enabled, the score obtained by counting the gloss overlaps is normalized by the size of the glosses. The details are described in Banerjee and Pedersen (2002). =back =head1 RELATION FILE FORMAT The relation file starts with the string "RelationFile" on the first line of the file. Following this, on each consecutive line, a relation is specified in the form -- func(func(func... (func)...))-func(func(func... (func)...)) [weight] Where "func" can be any one of the following functions: hype() = Hypernym of hypo() = Hyponym of holo() = Holonym of mero() = Meronym of attr() = Attribute of also() = Also see sim() = Similar enta() = Entails caus() = Causes part() = Particle pert() = Pertainym of glos = gloss (without example) example = example (from the gloss) glosexample = gloss + example syns = synset of the concept Each of these specifies a WordNet relation. And the outermost function in the nesting can only be one of glos, example, glosexample or syns. The set of functions to the left of the "-" are applied to the first word sense. The functions to the right of the "-" are applied to the second word sense. An optional weight can be specified to weigh the contribution of that relation in the overall score. For example, glos(hype(hypo))-example(hype) 0.5 means that the gloss of the hypernym of the hyponym of the first synset is overlapped with the example of the hypernym of the second synset to get the lesk score. This score is weighted 0.5. If "glos", "example", "glosexample" or "syns" is not provided as the outermost function of the nesting, the measure assumes "glos" as the default. So, glos(hypo(also))-glos(holo(attr)) and hypo(also)-holo(attr) are treated the same by the measure. =head1 SEE ALSO perl(1), WordNet::Similarity(3), WordNet::QueryData(3) http://www.cs.utah.edu/~sidd http://wordnet.princeton.edu http://www.ai.mit.edu/~jrennie/WordNet http://groups.yahoo.com/group/wn-similarity =head1 AUTHORS Ted Pedersen, University of Minnesota Duluth tpederse at d.umn.edu Satanjeev Banerjee, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh banerjee+ at cs.cmu.edu Siddharth Patwardhan, University of Utah, Salt Lake City sidd at cs.utah.edu =head1 BUGS None. To report bugs, go to http://groups.yahoo.com/group/wn-similarity/ or e-mail "S". =head1 COPYRIGHT AND LICENSE Copyright (c) 2005, Ted Pedersen, Satanjeev Banerjee and Siddharth Patwardhan This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either version 2 of the License, or (at your option) any later version. This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU General Public License for more details. You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License along with this program; if not, write to The Free Software Foundation, Inc., 59 Temple Place - Suite 330, Boston, MA 02111-1307, USA. Note: a copy of the GNU General Public License is available on the web at L and is included in this distribution as GPL.txt. =cut